The Los Angeles Chargers, despite pressing needs at receiver and running back positions, opted for a more traditional, physical approach in the first round of the 2024 NFL Draft by selecting former Notre Dame offensive tackle Joe Alt. This decision, reminiscent of Jim Harbaugh’s style, has garnered mixed reactions.
Many across the league are enthusiastic about Alt’s potential, considering his impressive stature and All-American status. They view him as a valuable asset in protecting Pro Bowl quarterback Justin Herbert. However, Alex Insdorf of Chargers Wire, while generally approving of the pick, questions whether passing on a top-tier wide receiver prospect for a solid but imperfect second-rounder like Georgia’s Ladd McConkey was the best move.
Despite speculation about other potential picks or trading down, the Chargers remained steadfast and selected Alt at the fifth spot, considering him the best player available. Insdorf acknowledges Alt’s stellar performance in limiting pressures and sacks last season, solidifying his status as the top tackle in the draft. However, he raises concerns about whether Alt was the optimal choice, especially given the enticing wide receiver options like Malik Nabers and Rome Odunze they passed on.
Another point of contention is Alt’s transition to right tackle, as he primarily played left tackle in college. While there’s confidence from the Chargers’ leadership that he can make the switch, questions linger about the adjustment, especially with Rashawn Slater likely occupying the left tackle position.
In summary, the Chargers’ selection of Joe Alt has sparked debates regarding their draft strategy, particularly their prioritization of offensive line talent over dynamic wide receiver prospects and the challenges Alt may face in adapting to a new position at the professional level.
